patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Letter: Firefighters' 24-Hour Shift Is A 'Complete Disaster'

Former Town Councilor Chuck Brennan urges residents to email the current council.

 

To the editor,

What is going on between the Town of North Kingstown and the North Kingstown Fire Department? Relations have been bad for the last year when the Town Council forced the firefighters to work 24 hour shifts but things could have changed for the better this week. Unfortunately, that didn’t happen.

The first thing that happened was that the Town Council took up the issue of the new fireboat again. Last year the previous council, of which I was a member, took up the issue during several meetings. The fire department obtained a homeland security grant of $830,000 to purchase a new boat. Our council voted to approve the purchase after several meetings and discussion and the boat was ordered.

One person emailed the council after discussions and voting to question the need for the boat. The fire department has a multi-faceted job on the water when called to service. They can fight fires, conduct medical rescues and search and rescue to name a few. We want them to be prepared with the right equipment. Councilman Dick Welch is quoted in the Standard Times as saying “I am not trying to second guess what the council did before….”He is then quoted as saying “I don’t understand the need for it….” Councilman Welch, I would say that is questioning the last council. Fire Chief Fenwick Gardiner has given the council assurances as to maintenance and manning the vessel but they are still wavering. Assistant Town Solicitor Don Maroney has said that if this council reverses itself they could open the town to liability for work already done on the boat in the hundreds of thousands of dollars.

Last night I was reading online that the Town Council had again reversed itself in regards to the fire department in terms of a contract. I was glad to read that the town and the fire department were negotiating for a new contract. That was a positive move after all of the legal wrangling, lawyers' bills, arbitration and ill-advised and illegal ordinance changes designed to wreak havoc on the fire department.  This all came after Judge Brian Stern had ordered the Town to reinstate the firefighters to their original shift last month.

Both sides had apparently hammered out a contract and it was set for a vote within the fire union on Friday. The fire union voted to approve the pact on Friday and then in an unbelievable move Saturday, the council voted 5-0 to reject the contract. My understanding is that there were handshakes between both sides after negotiations ended and the town manager signed the agreement.

Back to my original question. What is going on between the Town of North Kingstown and the North Kingstown Fire Department? What should have happened is that the council moved on the other pressing business rather than revisit the boat issue. They could have just thanked the firefighters for their work in obtaining this grant as well as the many other grants they obtained in the last year to offset costs to the tax payers.

Going back to the end of 2011 when the town's labor lawyer, Dan Kinder, presented an idea to the council to force the firefighters to work a 24-hour shift I said it was wrong. I told the council it violated collective bargaining, it would be costly to the town in terms of litigation and cause long term hard feelings with the fire department. All of that has happened. After Judge Stern came out with his original decision I asked the council to reverse their decision in August 2012 because they were violating Judge Stern's order and I was again out voted. In December 2012 Judge Stern told them to “unring the bell” as to wages, hours or work and other conditions of employment. He also ordered the town to put the firefighters back on their original schedule.

This has gone far enough. This council had an agreement with the fire department that by my reading could have saved taxpayers $1 million dollars in terms of the liability Judge Stern said may exist. I think it is time for this council to start dealing fairly with the fire department. The move they made to force the 24-hour shift has been a complete disaster. It has not saved the town money as the Republicans said it would. It has cost us hundreds of thousands of dollars in legal expenses and yet here we are. If you think the council should do the right thing, please email them as towncouncil@northkingstown.org.

 

Chuck Brennan

North Kingstown resident

Related Topics: 24-hour shifts, Dan Kinder, Local 1651, North Kingstown Fire Department, North Kingstown Town Council, and North Kingstown firefighters

ru4real

12:35 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

The TC has proven how disingenuous they are by the rejection of their own agreement. Their true motivations have now been exposed by their own foolishness. They are not to be trusted in any manner! The taxpayers of NK should be outraged by the continued arrogance of these people.
They have no interest in the collective well being of NK.

THIS TC SHOULD BE RECALLED, ALL FIVE OF THEM! Their insolence cannot be tolerated anymore! They have proven that they are not in anyway trying to improve the situation in NK. They are solely interested in their own misguided views which are making NK look like a mockery.

"We The People" need to put a halt to this foolishness!

Reply

NK Parent

1:08 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

What is the recall procedure? How difficult is it to get the ball rolling?

If reports are correct, Carol Hueston was on the negotiating team, made a handshake on the deal, and then voted against it. If anyone should be considered for recall, it's her.

Reply
Comment_arrow

ru4real

8:30 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

@NK Parent--the recall process is difficult (due to the changes that the previous Republican TC slipped through) and will require a very concerted effort by a very dedicated and committed group of concerned citizens. My experience is that (I say this will all due respect) talk is cheap but the effort is the real deal. Few, when the chips are down really have the huevos to due the deal. I am more than happy to be involved but I will not be an army of one! We need a way to contact each other and organize the effort.

NK_Voter

3:51 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

This disagreement is about who has the right to set the cost and conditions for town employees--is it the town or the public employees?

Frankly, I sympathize with the FF's--it's tough to change. Towns and cities, however, can't afford the generous wages and benefits offered in the past. With the teachers contract coming up, I think most overburdened NK taxpayers would prefer the town council in the driver's seat--not the teachers union. Which, perhaps, is why they were just elected.

Finally, I note there is nothing in this opinion piece stating what North Kingstown needs haven't been met by our FF's operating (for some time) under the current 24 hr schedule. And what's wrong with questioning the need to maintain and staff a boat that sees little use? Questions are good--it's how we make good decisions. Straight answers--or opinion pieces--that don't shade would be even better.

Reply

Rhodeyresident0303

4:13 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

Two things NK_Voter

Currently the North Kingstown firefighters are one of the lowest paid firefighters in the state. Even central falls who just came out of bankruptcy pays their firefighters more than the town of north Kingstown pays their firefighters. There are firefighters currently making 15 dollars an hour. It is no wonder why they just lost 4 guys to the warwick fire department and possibly more to other departments.

Reply

Rhodeyresident0303

4:14 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

And the fire boat will cost money to maintain but there is a 5 year warranty on it. The boat is operated by firefighters already on shift. Just like it is done with the current boat.

Reply

cheeeze

4:44 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

NK Voter, it comes down to one thing...THE LAW. The town council swore to uphold the Constitution of the United States and the laws of the State of Rhode Island when they took their oath of office. They have violated that oath and the law. They continue to throw good money after bad, how is that in any way in the best interest of the NK taxpayer? If the system was enacted properly (full staffing of the department and 4 platoons) then these hard working men and women wopuld not be working 48, 72, 96 hours straight(Que the "But they get to sleep" comments). Take it from someone with knowledge of the fire service. Phones ringing, lights going on/off, radios squaking hardly allow for any type of quality rest. It wears on people, and when that starts to happen, quality of service suffers. There's no room for that in the fire service.
As for the boat, it's a must have. Yes, they break down, but so does every piece of equipment. I've seen firetrucks that spend more time in the shop than in the station. It's the nature of the beast. NK has many waterfront assets that merit having a boat for search, rescue, and firefighting.

Reply
Comment_arrow

NK_Voter

11:13 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

Laws change, and I think it is within the law for a town's elected officials to decide the working conditions and pay they can afford.

You offer a lot of opinion.....little fact. Why is the boat a " must have"? Is there a law specifying this requirement? And we are constantly told how hard these 24 hr shifts are...but no data offered. We are told the NKFD had three thousand calls last year. Given three stations, that averages less than 3 calls per 24 hours in a year--and most of those calls are for paramedics. Nobody is saying FF's don't have a dangerous, at times, job. But please explain to use, with facts, how 3 calls a day, on average, and working 10 days a month, is "wearing".

Rhodeyresident0303

6:14 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

I'd also like to state that so far the coverage on this topic from the patch has been horrible !!! Barely any up to date info!!!!

Reply
Comment_arrow

ru4real

8:37 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

What else is new! They shill for the Republican party in town and rarely (show me the articles) if ever, are critical of local government in any manner whatsoever.
They are a vanilla forum for hissing and spitting. They are not in any way, shape or form a critical news organization.

Rhodeyresident0303

8:42 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

Agreed!! It's a shame independentri or ri central dont have this type of forum. NKPatch just isn't cutting it !!! Poor coverage thus far .. That picture of the elections last year of the nktc using the patch computer makes one wonder.. but it is Especially sad that independent bloggers and the providence journal have more details and information regarding this whole topic

Reply

Pam

9:01 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

Most firefighters in America work a 24-hour shift. Not sure why it's causing such a problem here, tho I did hear reference to it negatively affecting firefighters' second jobs. The bottom line is the bottom line at this point. The taxes in NK are dramatically -- dramatically -- higher than other towns in South county, including Jamestown and Narragansett. Sympathy in short supply.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Tired of NK antics

9:40 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

Good points all, Pam. Don't let the union sympathizers or firefighters intimidate you in an attempt silence your opinion.

Comment_arrow

Stanley Martin

6:07 am on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

MOST firefighters are not a combination department. Do you know what the means Pam?

Comment_arrow

ru4real

7:16 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Do you get paid to shill for the Republican TC? You need to do a better job of fact checking. You haven't a clue about the 24 hr shift issues and all the peripheral issues involved. Have another drink of Kool Aid.
This is and has been an ill conceived scheme by our town manager and the TC and it is giving NK a very big black eye.
Just as an aside, there will never be a decision to uphold the NK TC in this dispute because they are legally in the wrong, end of story! All they do is continually throw away tax dollars---THEY NEED TO BE RECALLED, ALL FIVE OF THEM! They are disgraceful as representatives of the people of NK.
This is an example of wrongly elected arrogance that all of us have to pay for and that all of us have to suffer for in the long run. The previous TC and the current TC are hell bent on destroying this town and they are well on their way to accomplishing that goal.
I have asked the question before and I ask it again HAVE YOU HAD ENOUGH YET?

Comment_arrow

I'm Tired of the Games

8:29 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Pam:

Yes, many do work a 24 hr shift, but they do it on a 4 platoon system, not 3 platoons. Most also have sufficient, not dwindling manpower to staff the shifts. They also are compensated for each hour at the rate called for in their contract, not some whimsical figure a rogue TC deems appropriate without negotiations in violation of State law.

Rhodeyresident0303

9:25 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

Pam go back to Pinterest or Facebook .. You have no idea what your talking about

Reply

RS

10:38 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

Pam, how about you work and extra 14 hours a week for free. The argument isn't the 24 hour shifts, its how they were implemented and the 56 hour work week. Yes, lots of places work 24s but most use 4 shifts, not 3.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Tired of NK antics

11:23 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

RS, try working at the same job for 4 years with no raise, no cola, no shift differential and paying 27% co-pay. Just the same salary as 4 years ago and taking home less. Talk to some people in the private sector and see how their pay has changed and how their lifestyles have been affected.

Comment_arrow

RS

11:51 pm on Monday, February 4, 2013

Lets see, no raise 3 years here, I don't get a COLA on my pension, 20% copay and the Town is stealing my pension money for a pension I will never see. I've worked in the private sector and I took a pay cut to be here. NK, where were you when the economy was good and no one wanted municiple jobs???? Didn't hear you crying then.

Comment_arrow

Tired of NK antics

1:18 am on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Hey RS, I am not crying. It's you ff's that are doing all the crying. You all need to realize that taxpayers have no more to give to support unrealistic union demands. You said you took a pay cut to be a ff. Nobody forced you, did they? You can't expect others to make up the difference for your poor financial decision. If being a ff no longer provides you the lifestyle you want, find another employer.

Comment_arrow

RS

11:51 am on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

NK, I'm not complaining. I knew what I was getting into when I signed up. Point I was making is that I took the job abnd paycut back when no one wanted those jobs because you traded off getting rich for job security. It was a bonus I loved the job. Now they are changing the rules at the end of my career. Its basically...hey thanks for giving up what you had, and now we're taking everything away that you've planned for. We held up our side of the agreement, paid our pension contribution, worked our shifts and then the Council decides that they are going to use the Fire Union as a "test case". They knew that changing the shifts broke the law but they did it anyway, and they are stubborn enough to go all the way to the Supreme Court? Seems a couple other Town or Cities got almost the same thing thru negociations and it didn't cost the taxpayers huge legal bills.

cheeeze

6:11 am on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

NK Voter states "Laws change. I think it is within the law for a town's elected officials to decide the working conditions and pay they can afford". Laws do change, through legislative process, not at the whim of town councils. What's to stop them from passing any ordinance about the color of your house? Could you afford the paint? Seems trivial, but if the town council just changed ordinances at the drop of a hat affecting NK residents financially, all would be up in arms. But because this ordinance only affects "union thugs", it's OK. The town council will lose this battle, but not after many appeals. Dan Kinder will walk away with a ton of your money, smiling all the way to the bank. The firefighters will be due back pay, and the longer this goes on with appeals, the larger that number is going to get. I may have my "opinions", but the law is the law.

Reply

NK_Voter

8:27 am on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Here's a fairly balanced article. I think it answers Cheeze's rant.
I also notice that you didn't have answers to my other questions, Cheeze. Lots of opinion, no facts. Nice.

Reply

cheeeze

8:41 am on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

NK voter, I stand corrected, You are absoulutely correct. I have no facts, only opinions. Good job on calling me out on my "rant". Here are some facts. I've rescued people with a fire boat, I've recovered bodies with a fire boat. The Coast Guard did respond, but after the fact. Lives have been saved, families have been given closure thanks to the actions of local area departments and the capabilities of their boats. Whether or not, in your or my opinion, the NKFD needs a new boat will never be agreed upon. This comment section is all about opinion. When facts get thrown into it, they get skewed and twisted into opinion. So I could post all the facts, and get questioned about sources. It's just not worth the time.

To those on the job in NKFD, best of luck.

Reply
Comment_arrow

NK_Voter

9:45 am on Wednesday, February 6, 2013

Glad you agree. The truth shall set you free.

Rhodeyresident0303

9:30 am on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Nk voter you stated the the NKFD did 3000 calls last year where did you get your information because according to the secretary for the fire department the department did 5000 runs last year.

Reply
Comment_arrow

NK_Voter

9:46 am on Wednesday, February 6, 2013

Define "call." Is a "call" a response? And even so, what does that come out to--an average of 4.5 calls in a 24 hr period? And the FF's work 10 days a month? And how many of those where for the paramedics? The vast majority?

I understand that it's a great job with benefits few dream of. I understand they want the gravy train to keep running. I can't afford their desires, however. Especially as there has been NO effect on coverage for NK with the 24 hr shifts despite all the hyperbole and claims of doom and gloom. I also understand the pro-union laws in this state and the lock the unions have. It's one reason this state is almost dead last in every measure but corruption.

If the FF's/unions don't like the schedule/pay, go elsewhere. I'm sure their will be others waiting to assist the people on NK.

nkres

11:35 am on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

I still have yet to hear the reasoning why the TC rejected an agreement that was approved by thier own Negotiating team. They hired the team to negotiate on thier behalf, then rejected thier work. Does this mean the TC has no faith or trust in thier own team? Time to fire Embury and Kinder then, since they are just costing the town money by performing work that is not in approval by the TC. DIdn't the team get any input from the TC before signing the agreement? What else does Embury do that the TC doesn't approve of?
It's simular to hiring a contractor to remodel your home with your own plans, then demolish the home. Seems insane.

Reply

wickchevy

12:05 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

You can tell who the Fireman, Residents and the Town Council are behind these blog names. I support the Residents and Fireman! This "test case" just proves the Council and Town Manager are breaking the laws. The Fireman should get paid for every hour worked.

Reply
Comment_arrow

Tired of NK antics

12:20 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

they are getting paid for every hour worked, just not as much as they think they deserve.

wickchevy

1:42 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

That is not true. Thankfully for the Fireman the Judge sees through your smoke and mirrors...

Reply

Support NK

9:32 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

Let's see ToNKa run into a burning building for less pay and no respect from certain residents of NK. These people DESERVE what they are already getting and MORE!

Reply
Comment_arrow

Tired of NK antics

11:20 pm on Tuesday, February 5, 2013

@support nk, If that was my chosen vocation I would. But fortunately for me I chose to make my own way, not dependent on holding taxpayers hostage for pay increases regardless of the quality or quantity of work I provide.

Leave a comment